Dec 03, 2008

I've seen police records ,you have called the cops more then once, not only on Carmen but on other people on Donald.

This story has changed more than the weather.. I have been following this story very closely and I am very unclear about some things. First off, you claim you/your family had only called the cops once on the Granata household? There is proven facts, police records, that show that you've called more than once. How can we believe ANYTHING you say if you have just proven yourself to be a liar?! Also, you are making complete accusations against the Granata household. The rock that was supposedly thrown through the window at your household matches the ones that are in front of the Granata home is what you said. You have claimed a few weeks ago that it was a 15lb rock. From what I've heard, the police gone to the Granata's and said it looked like one of their landscaping PEBBLES (any pebble that weighs 15lbs is NOT a pebble, nor a rock, its a boulder.) If there was a "suspicious" vehicle that had left the scene, how come that person was not questioned or held for the crime?

Please answer these questions. Myself and I'm sure many others ponder over your accusations and allegations.

It seems people who keep trying to slam this women and her family are getting a little scared!

It doesn't matter how many times they called the police ! Dont give them any reason and I'm sure they wouldn't have to call in the first place!

I know people that hang out with Carmen and her buddies and I can say that there not sweet and innocent like they keep trying to act!

I know what happens at there party's I've seen them get way out of hand! Thats why I chose not to hang out with them anymore! They even spray paint eachother and other things I'm not gonna even mention!

I hope this family with the children find justice !

Come on people if you know anything just give them up $750.00 is alot of money If I knew I would.

 Believe me They  probaly have something to do with it ! There that kind of people and I would'nt put it past them!

One more thing to JohnJ quit picking on a girl or does that make you feel like a man!

Well you guys asked her to tell you the truth and she did what you asked!

Nobody is picking on carmen .I agree with this women because if I had children I would want to know too! I give her credit for not giving up!

Dont worry about what theses people are saying ! Dont give up your fight ! I admire you, Your Brave! And all the right people can read between the lines and see that there just scared because its just a matter of time till the WHOLE  truth will come out!!!!!!!!

I Highly doubt that! If anybody should be ashamed it should be carmen and her friends!

Also this lady did not mention them untill you people got on here and dared her to tell the truth so leave these  people alone!

They have there rights to speak there mind just like you guys did on goeastpointe about 4 different post you guys posted.

This is a public place for people to tell there stories and to get info out there! If you dont like what she wrote then dont read it!

Maybe carmen or mario didnt throw the rock themselves but I'm sure they have an idea of who did!  One more thing : ScudWeDontLoveYou!!!!!!!!!!!

Listen, someone out there has to know who threw the rock through the window of this home.  Why not do the right thing and tell the authorities who is responsible?   Help out someone who needs it.  What if this was you, would you not want some assistance?

To those of you who continually put your 2 cents into it without having any proof to support your ridicules bashing, you need to get a life and stay out of this.  Your time could be better spent I am certain, perhaps mentor a child, teach someone to read, volunteer all your "time" at a food kitchen.  You seem to be such perfect people - why not share all your perfection with those who need it and stop trying to make others feel bad about themselves.  Unless, of course, this is how you make yourselves feel that you are truly the good people you think you are.  I hate to sound cliche, and there is no pun intended, but people who live in glass houses shouldn't through stones!

As to the family - keep up with this.  Eventually someone will come forward with some information.  Until then I pray that you and your children are able to heal and not allow this to dictate how you live your lives. God Bless.

PEACE.

"It does not mean to be in a place, where there is no noise, trouble or hard work. It means to be in the midst of those things and still  be calm in your heart"

I see the problem here. It's called "tunnel-vision".  You are so obsessed with hating your neighbors so much that you forget that Eastpointe isn't the cute cozy little town people think it is.  Maybe it was somebody who knows Carmen, maybe not.  I do know that Carmen does NOT know who did it and does NOT condone the action by any means. So you really need to back off of her and stop bashing her already.  She's gone through way more than she needed to because of you.

Honestly, if her friends were littering and urinating on you lawn, you should have called the cops on her FRIENDS!  You put ALL the blame on Carmen when nothing is directly her fault.  Maybe she could choose her friends better but thats not for me or YOU to decide, it's her life.

Also, maybe you could use a physics lesson.  Have you ever tried to throw a 15lb rock?  I'll give you a hint on how hard it is. The heaviest Shot Put weighs 16lbs and was only thrown 75ft.  Meaning that for the average person to throw it THROUGH your window and have it land anywhere but JUST inside the window, they would have to be standing no more that a few feet away. Especially considering the amount of energy the window would absorb before breaking. A much smaller stone thrown from farther away would likely only crack the window.

What i'm getting at is your story doesn't jive.  And you continually bringing this up instead of telling your kids that there are just bad people in the world is whats damaging to them.  You really really really need to move on, for your kids sake.  Stop the witch hunt to find more ways to get your neighbors in trouble, because this almost seems to be whats happening.

I don't know if you watch the news much, but I see Eastpointe on the news at least once a week and it's not good stuff. Who ever posted this story is doing it in all the wrong ways. I understand you want to find out who broke your window but by pointing fingers and bashing people is very child like. I search the whole internet on this story, do you really think after Carmen got a ticket for being loud, a week later she would throw a rock or what ever it was at your window? Come on now! Did you ever think that it was just some young kids pulling pranks and they happen to pick your house? What if it was Carmen's window that got broke, would it be ok for her to point fingers and bash you just because you guys don't see eye to eye. Think about  it    

I'm sure this family thought that might be the case,but if you read her comment about all the evidence supporting her claim it does seem to be suspicious.The rocks in front of her house,The vehicle leaving the scene ,tell me something then if it was not by you people then the vehicle that left the scene must have seen something or someone if they left at the same time the rock went through the window? Come on people it's a little obvious if they didnt have nothing to do with it why not say what you seen  then so this family can move on and also everybody else on that street.

$750.00 is alot of money and it could do alot for some people so why not just give it up already.I feel this family had suffered enough with all the media and he-said she-said crap and there names being smeared all over I read them all so dont say you havent done this because you have .All they did is called the police because they were trying to sleep .They didnt deserve a rock through there window or any of this .It seems these people are good law abideing citizens that were a little annoyed .Wonder if that rock would have hit that child ?God it just sickens me how crazy people are and who just dont give a crap anymore!